Saturday, 1 December 2018

The People Speak Ed Colin Firth & Anthony Arnove



500 ish pages which I have read over 5 years ish.

The content is interesting in and of itself – speaking in various historical contexts and on various issue.

However the whole is really interesting. “The People” is complex – it feels a little dated and New Labour – making us think of Diana “The People’s” Princess.

Equally at this moment in time “The People’s Vote” is a hot topic – somehow differentiating it from when the people voted in recent General Elections or in earlier Referendums.

The Sub-title is “Voices that changed Britain” but it is I think only voices that changed Britain for “good” as defined by the Editors. A future edition is unlikely to include a speech from Nigel Farage, despite his impact on Britain. The copy I have has a Red Flag on the cover which probably indicates the starting point of the Editors.

Friday, 30 November 2018

The Last Man in Russia by Oliver Bullough



Russia is a fascinating country – Churchill, in typically quotable style, called it a riddle wrapped in a mystery inside an enigma. Those of us who remember the Cold War perhaps put too much of its difference down to Communism, but while a number of the Countries of the Warsaw Pact have integrated into the EU and the “European” consensus - Russia remains apart. We stand at a moment when Francis Fukuyama’s “End of History” has never seemed more foolhardy.

Bullough focuses his exploration of Russia through an exploration of the life of one man, Father Dmitry. He travels, and the descriptions of those travels are vivid and engaging – even if the content is long hours on cold buses.

There is an Orwellian tragedy about Father Dmitry – for so long a Saint, but then broken by the State – recanting and capitulating – ending his days a bitter and troubled soul. It is a narrative worthy of Dostoevsky. That light that shone so bright was crushed, that one who showed such strength could be defeated, is horrific – if the State is stronger than even Father Dmitry then perhaps all resistance is futile.

The blurb on the back of the book says “Bullough shows that in a country so willing to crush its citizens, there is also courage, resilience and flickering glimmers of hope.”. Perhaps it is reading with the knowledge of the events of the last 5 years since this book was published – but I struggled to see the hope and I can’t recall reading, for all Bullough’s skill as a writer, such a depressing book.

Sand by Hugh Howey



Includes spoilers!

Set in a dystopia future Howey has the knack of giving a sense of realism, characters that you could relate with, reactions that had humanity about them. The relationships are strong and believable.

I found this a captivating narrative – people living in a world that had limitations, physical but also in terms of knowledge – they know of some relics of a former civilisation but had no real understanding of the context of those artefacts. A sense that the glimpses of past glories were a tease to them in such reduced circumstances.

It becomes clear that the situation they are in is the effect of the actions of other people living elsewhere, and worse still that those others are aware of the negative effects of their actions. It is not a natural desert they are struggling with, it is man-made.

The is a tension in the ending – a strike back, understandable but violent – an event off-stage, but probably a nuclear explosion – relief for the suffering of this community but at what cost?

There are metaphors for us in the “West” - we are those living in the other place, our lifestyles have negative impacts on many elsewhere in the world, be it climate change or the exploitation of workers for cheap goods, and we know but mostly choose to ignore those consequences. But how do you assign guilt to a whole civilisation – even the well intentioned struggle to extract themselves from exploitative structures?

Saturday, 13 October 2018

Interruption Silence by Walter Brueggemann and Into the Silent Land by Martin Laird



It was a coincidence that I read these two reflections on Silence so close together. They explore different contexts of silence – Brueggemann silence in the political and social realm, Laird silence in the personal and spiritual.

One argues for the breaking of silence, the other for the holding of ever deeper experience of it.

If I am honest I didn’t get on that well with either book, while nevertheless agreeing with the essence of the point both were making.

I found Brueggemann, who is generally a wise and subtle writer, rather shouty – there was too much about confrontation – it seemed to suggest that it is easy, just speak out and you will be heard and the world a better place. It didn’t do enough to explore the subtle ways in which silence falls, how you are tempted to keep quiet, how the voices of many are denied.

However the power of silence as a means of control, a tool that favours the powerful and the status quo, is clear – and I would entirely agree that “There is no practical area in the life of the church in which reform is more urgent than in the church’s propensity (in all of its manifestations)to silence.”

Laird is offering a practical guide for the development of contemplative practice – how you can build up toward the the holding of times of sustained silence (during which God might speak).

He uses an interesting image, that “a gardener does not actually grow plants. A gardener practices certain gardening skills that facilitate growth that is beyond the gardener’s direct control.” This can be applied to much Christian ministry – we are probably comfortable saying that the Priest does not “convert” people but practices certain skills that facilitate “conversion”. We can also talk about prayer in these terms – we don’t actually “pray” but instead engage in certain practices that allow prayer to happen. It is less about me praying TO God, but prayer being a time of communication between me and God.

I would also agree with Laird when he concludes that “sadly much liturgical prayer is often hopelessly cerebral, self-conscious, verbose, and distracted...”

He later says that there “is a certain wisdom that settles into a life that does not attempt to control what everybody else ought to be thinking, saying, doing, or voting on.” This would appear to be a state of being that is almost the exact opposite of Facebook and social media…

I guess what a struggled with was the way it felt that Laird was prescribing a particular set of practices to everyone, regardless of their context or their personality type. I would agree with the objective, creating space for God to speak, for God to take us by surprise – but I think perhaps there is room for other methods – for some of us our brains are perhaps just too restless for sustained silence – they need something to do to stop the thoughts going round and round and chasing their tails.

Thursday, 20 September 2018

In Parenthesis by David Jones



This is writing totally other from almost everything else we are fed. Complex, rich, demanding total attention.

What stands out for me is the balance between the waiting and the action. This is something that I feel is being lost – yes the moments of action were horrific but it was the moments of inaction that really ate away at people’s souls.

Lovechild by Herbert Williams



I was engaged with this book, but somehow it failed to come to a resolution.

Steve, the central character, is not particularly likeable – maybe it is an honesty about the narrative that he is not offered redemption, nevertheless people move on with their lives.

Maybe I didn’t believe anyone, but in particular I struggled to believe the women – their reactions didn’t fit with the likely reactions of the women I know.

Addlands by Tom Bullough



It is a novel full of pathos about the struggles of Welsh hill farms – and however powerful I found this story I could not stake off the feeling that, essentially, I had been here before.

It is a very well executed example of a pretty standard narrative – rugged landscape, fractured masculinity, authenticity born out of economic marginality – it ticks all the boxes ...