Saturday, 13 April 2013

Clergy Robes by Andrew Atherstone and Dressing for Worship by Dick Hines

Clergy Robes and Mission Priorities (Worship Series)
 Dressing for Worship: A Fresh Look at What Christians Wear in Church


Grove Books have a well deserved reputation for providing high quality and accessible material which enriches the life of the Church by encouraging thoughtful engagement in key issues among the general reader. 

Andrew Atherstone’s Clergy Robes and Mission Priorities can therefore only be understood as the exception that proves the rule.  His starting point is that Clergy Robes are a barrier to Mission, however he advances no evidence to substantiate this.  Instead this is an unremitting tirade against the rules of the Church of England based on the assumption that those who uphold these rules are backward, blinkered, and ignorant.

Dick Hines’ Dressing for Worship, which is amongst Andrew Atherstone’s bibliography, is a much more worthy offering.  It is a useful foundation for considering the position of the Church of England on clergy dress, acknowledging the deep tradition of giving clergy distinctive outfits and the many positive arguments in favour of the retention of this practice.  It does also give space for consideration of the down side of this practice and the reasons why some feel that the obligation on clergy to robe should be removed.

No comments:

Post a Comment