Tales
of the City
Buy it from Hive.co.uk and support local booksellers
We
have an exciting gang of people, a zesty buzz to their interactions –
and I just want to know what happens next…
Maupin
is providing us with a Soap Opera, which I don’t see as a negative
comment. Our mainstream Soap Operas have in recent years explored a
range of stories drawing on the experiences of LGBT+ people and in
some ways I think it is important to remember how different the
context in which Maupin was writing was. This volume published in
1980, perhaps a high water mark for movements of liberation started
in the 1960s before the crisis of Aids and right-wing retrenchment
took hold.
These
stories remain very fresh, young people testing their identities –
those across the generations wrestling with social expectations –
all of them struggling, at some level, to be comfortable in their own
bodies, in their own lives.
The
is a comedy to many of the situations, not because they are played
for laughs but because quite often life is fairly ridiculous.
Further
Tales of the City
Within
the delightful dramas of this instalment of the Tales it is Michael
Tolliver ongoing struggles with love and identity which perhaps have
the greatest power – it is a theme that feels so fresh. There is
an exploration of ways in which Michael finds self-acceptance as a
gay man a particular challenge – he has internalised some of
society’s negative assumptions and can’t let himself embrace the
love that is there to surround him.
Babycakes
There
is a warmth in encountering the cast of characters again, they are
becoming old friends… The situations have perhaps been pushed even
further yet there is such life to them that they become believable.
Michael
Tolliver’s visit to London is a window to the past of the City,
especially the gay past of the City, that feels more remote that the
years would suggest.
Significant
Others
The
unfolding of the AIDS crisis increasingly dominates this tale and
Michael Tolliver’s loneliness.
As
usual there are powerful ideas explored within the comedy to the
situations that play out – weaving the two together – for example
towards the end DeDe and D’Or share moment of mutual confession and
forgiveness which is captured “In a burst of hideous insight, DeDe
realized the depth of her commitment to this marriage. She had just
traded adultery for a cheeseburger and an order of french fries.”
At
one point Michael reflects that “nothing would ever happen, no one
would ever care until straight people started getting it.” - that
AIDS was just a gay problem and therefore for not worth worrying
about – I think Diana played a big part in changing that for us,
but we need to be constantly watchful for those things that impact
the lives of the marginalised and minorities which we allow
ourselves, as “normal” people, to ignore.
Sure
of You
Buy it from Bookshop.org and support local booksellers
This
is the final of the first run of novels although it doesn’t read as
a finale, so I am glad to know that this are more books for me to go
on a read.
I
think reading this directly after Black
Deutschland set a context, both being set in a similar time, but
I am not sure exactly what that context was…
There
is a domesticity to this episode, the nesting of Michael and Thack
had an echo of Hide
by Matthew Griffin but it is there too, in a funny sort of way,
in Brian and Mary-Ann’s break up. A particular ache and intensity
of love in the ordinary not the Rom-Com soft focus fluff.
The
shadow that HIV/AIDS hangs over Michael made me almost weepy – the
fear about getting ill but also the stigma – we are still not over
that, the dragging of heels to make PREP freely available is the
currently playing out of the stigma, in not so subtle ways it
reinforces our belief that gay men are dirty and should know better.
It makes me feel sad and tired. We snatch space of our love, we can’t
take it for granted.
Reading
it in Gran Canaria I was mindful that staying in hotel where around a
third of guests were same-sex couples you start to feel normalised in
a way that you are not in day to day life, however much we have
formal equality, and the chance to be in such space is a privilege.
Maybe
the Moon
Buy it from Bookshop.org and support local booksellers
This
is not part of the “Tales of the City” but it is a close
relation. Cady has a view of Hollywood based on being on the margins,
because of her size, which perhaps allows the holding up of a mirror
in a way a true “insider” could not do.
Maupin
gives Cady the dignity of her sexuality, something that society
struggles to do for people whose bodies do not fit the “norm”. In
his playfulness he is able to explore “issues” without ever
preaching at you.
Writing
in 1992 a major part of the plot is closeted existence of a young gay
actor – sadly this aspect does not feel as dated as it really
should – there is some space for openly gay people within Hollywood
but it feels like it is still a limited and contested space.
The
Night Listener
Buy it from Bookshop.org and support local booksellers
This
is something of a Russian doll, storytelling within storytelling
within storytelling, and the sense of nothing being as it seems is an
unsettling delight.
There
is something warm and reassuring about a Maupin book – surprising
but familiar territory. I think it is enjoyable to read about the
dysfunctional lives of people who happen to be gay. Being gay is not
the root of the dysfunction – they have difficult relationships
with lovers, with parents, but so do most straight people. It is a
world complete in itself.
Michael
Tolliver Lives
Buy it from Bookshop.org and support local booksellers
This
return to the Tales of The City clearly carried risks, the best part
of 20 years had pasted between the publication of Sure of You and
Michael Tolliver Lives – years when the world of gay men in liberal
western cities was remade, 2007 may have been something of a high
point (LGBTQ+ life seemed to be getting ever better, the pathway to
full inclusion seemed inevitable in ways that now feel, frankly,
naive) – it was a moment when it could almost have felt like there
was nothing left to say.
But
it deals with being a middle aged gay man – and I have to put my
hand up and accept that I am perhaps reading this as the sweet spot
in terms of my own life – lots of things drive the “Peter Pan”
mentality of so many gay men, in this novel Armistead helps us let
that all go and be ourselves.
There
is also a little bit of a flavour of a greatest hits album, all the
old characters are name checked in ways that give the faithful reader
a warm glow but would be lost on anyone starting their journey here.
Mary
Ann in Autumn
Buy it from Bookshop.org and support local booksellers
Once
again we have the familiar cast, and as with Michael Tolliver Lives
it is an exploration of middle aged lives – how have the twists and
turns shaped these people, how have they found happiness, how have
they ended up still searching for it?
While
it was an enjoyable read there was a moment about two thirds of the
way through when I saw what the classic Maupin plot twist was going
to be, how the seemingly unconnected parts of the narrative were
going to turn out to be inextricably tied together – and I felt a
little flat when the big reveal finally came as I tried to politely
muster my surprised face…