Thursday, 20 September 2018

Nothing Has Changed by Adrian Masters



I put this along side The Greasy Poll by Mike Parker on the bookshelf – both being detailed reflections of election campaigns in Wales. The interface between Welsh and UK politics being a key part of the dynamic.

It is, for a political geek, an interesting account – but the most significant thing it reveals is the number of campaign events that are attended by the party faithful and the press. The “public” even in the midst of a hotly contested election are generally getting on with their lives elsewhere – better things to do than worry about who is running the country.

Wednesday, 19 September 2018

The Lifers’ Club by Francis Pryor



This is a pretty solid whodunit in which Francis Pryor does bring the essence of the Fens to the page.

However it often felt in need of a stronger editorial hand, description of details irrelevant to the plot were far too common. I don’t know if this is related to the crowdfunding model of the publishing house but I feel you could probably have cut the text by at least a third without significantly impairing the narrative.

SS-GB by Len Deighton



Having watched the recent BBC adaptation I was interested to read the book and see if the flaws in the TV version were there in the original.

Please note there will be some spoilers …

The book, like the TV, begins with an interesting exploration of the relationship between Detective Inspector Archer and the Nazi authorities now in charge. As part of the murder squad Archer separates his work from any agenda of the Nazis. His position is that murder is still murder, his job is to find the truth, and the truth doesn’t change depending on who is in power… however as the story unfolds this certainty begins to fall away – truth starts to look a lot more fluid.

But then somewhere along the way the novel, like the TV, seems to get completely lost – there is a plot to liberate the King from the tower of London, Archer ends up the driver of an ambulance that bundles the King into the back and drives out the open gates – only to break down and leave them in the midsts of a French farce pushing the King up the Strand in a wheelchair before ending up somewhere in the South West having a shoot out on the beach.

All the flaws of the TV adaptation are there in black and white…

Invasion by Luke Rhinehart


One of the books read on the plane home from Australia.

Sci-fi often provides an effective medium for satire on current affairs, but this is best achieved with a subtle touch that allows the reader to join the dots. In this instance Rhinehart is using a big fat marker pen and while there is some charm and humour to the “FF” especially Louie overall it is a pretty thin work.

Monday, 23 July 2018

Tunnel The Archaeology of Crossrail



At 120 pages, mostly containing pictures and a reasonable amount of white space (which in design terms is commendable), this falls into the category of sales brochure rather than serious analysis.

Sunday, 22 July 2018

British Rail Designed 1948-97 by David Lawrence



The British Rail Corporate Identity Manual published in 1965 gave expression to the idea of total design – absolutely ever part of BR was considered with every detail intended to give a unified message about the values of the organisation. Transport had long been a pioneer in marketing and design – London Transport set the standard while we remain fascinated by the railway posters of the 1920s and 1930s.

Post-war constraints on resources and the challenges of bringing the “Big Four” together (who hadn’t actually fully resolves the challenges of “Grouping” two decades earlier) meant that British Railways struggled with its identity. There was a step change when British Railways became British Rail – and perhaps against the odds somehow they got it right.

The monolithic BR Blue gave way in the 1980s to sector identities and then in the mid-1990s to the shadow companies ahead of privatisation. David Lawrence clearly feels every step away from BR Blue is a step in the wrong direction – is this ideological, it went hand in hand with the move away from Nationalised industry to the Private sector, from public service to commercial imperative. While the sectors brought diversity to the BR identity I feel it continue to hold on to the importance of quality design – I my room as I type the “art work” is 3 BR livery style sheets from the era of the sectors.

With privatisation railfreight seems to have retained good design, although with the advantage that their focus is their locos – EWS now DB, GB Railfreight, and DRS all have clear identities – in the passenger sector some have been good such as GNER, SWT, and recently GWR, others have been dreadfully but I won’t name names.

It is a fascinating topic, but despite the rich material David Lawrence has written a fairly boring book. I am a geek about trains, I am a geek about design, if you write a book about train design that doesn’t excite me you are in trouble…

Sunday, 15 July 2018

Musing of a Clergy Child by Nell Goddard



This book made me say “yes absolutely” and “wtf” in equal measure…

There are different sections …

It starts with a poem - Clergy child’s lament
“I didn’t choose it
you called my parents to it …
‘Incarnational ministry’ they call it
‘Invasion of personal space’ I respond …”

But the end point is being drawn into the calling too – the experience of some but not most Clergy Children – for most the lament goes on, the Church has blinded them to the God it claims to represent.

So we have Tips for Clergy Children – for the most part I agreed with these - the life of a child in a vicarage is a vibrant but at times problematic – Nell’s parents seems to run a very “open house” policy, my didn’t but we still lacked private space. Clergy should have professional boundaries between them and “the parish” if not for their own sake, then at the very least for the sake of their children.

Next were Letters – of these most powerful was “A letter for when the church has hurt you” and from another Letter “ vicars are human too, they often end up listening to the one who shouts the loudest and forget to hear the quiet voice of their child, just as needy but drowned out by the din of parishioners’ pastoral problems.” - but while acknowledging this pain they all end up on a breezy “Jesus loves you” tone.

Finally Musings – which I think had little to do with being a clergy child, but had the same paradox of talking of the deep pain many feel but somehow ending up very Churchy and the sense that if you just love Jesus a little more your problems will go away.

I know this is probably unfair but as a clergy child I don’t just carry scars thanks to the Church but a few, still, unhealed wounds. I celebrate that Nell has found a place deep within the Church, but I guess I want to read the same book written by one of the many Clergy Children that remain so beaten up by the Church that they can’t get across the threshold…